40 in a 30, a Mercedes van and a charge that quietly disappeared
Part 2 of a founder's day at Weymouth Magistrates' Court: a van driver is fined for speeding on the A35, and police drop the "who was driving?" charge.
Part 2 of 2 in the series A day at Weymouth Magistrates' Court
The second case I watched was the smallest, and it taught me the most about how a court list can mislead.
Tom Cutts was listed for trial on two charges. One was speeding on a 30mph road. The other was failing to give information identifying the driver, an offence under section 172 of the Road Traffic Act that carries six points on its own.
In court, the police prosecutor dropped the section 172 charge. Cutts admitted doing 40mph in a 30mph limit on the A35 on 4 February 2026, in a Mercedes van he uses for work. No officers attended. The case had started under the Single Justice Procedure, where magistrates decide cases on paper, before ending up in a courtroom.
Forty in a thirty is “Band A” under the Sentencing Council’s speeding guideline. That means a fine of 25–75% of weekly income and usually three points. He received credit for pleading guilty and was fined £100, with a £40 victim surcharge and £85 costs. The police had asked for £150 in costs.
What the data can’t see. If you only read the list, this looks like a contested case with a serious charge attached. In fact the serious charge was dropped and the case ended with a guilty plea to the smaller one. Across Weymouth since May, our data has 29 cases with a failure-to-identify charge. I’d like to know how many end like this one. Answering that properly needs results data, not just listings.
Part 2 of 3. I spent Monday 9 November in the public gallery at Weymouth Magistrates’ Court. Anyone can do the same: most hearings are open to the public. Reports are based on my notes from open court.